2Was the constitutional right to bank secrecy violated: Regarding Supreme Decree No. 430-2020-EF.

Reading Time:

9 min

Execution time: 0.0006 seconds

As of January 1, the Companies of the Financial System must report to SUNAT balances and yields greater than 10,000 soles. Although the measure seeks to improve control, it could violate the right to banking secrecy. The Constitutional Court could consider the measure unconstitutional due to lack of proportionality and temporality.

As from January 1st of this year, the Financial System Companies (ESF) are obliged to report monthly to the National Superintendence of Customs and Tax Administration - SUNAT, the balances, accumulated amounts and/or yields generated equal to or greater than ten thousand soles (or its equivalent in US dollars or other foreign currency), both of individuals and legal entities, with respect to each of their accounts in the financial system. This was established by Supreme Decree No. 430-2020-EF[1] and its Annex[2], by which the referred measure was approved.

As we know, the aforementioned Supreme Decree is based on Legislative Decree No. 1434[3], which had as one of its objectives to amend Article 143-A of Law No. 26702[4], in order to perfect the already recognized assumption of the provision of financial information by the SFEs to SUNAT, respecting the rights and principles set forth in the Political Constitution of Peru, including banking secrecy.

The purpose of this article is to explain whether the measure that obliges the Financial System Entities to inform SUNAT about the passive operations carried out by their clients for amounts equal to or greater than S/. 10,000.00, is constitutional or violates the right to banking secrecy.

As we know, the right to banking secrecy is set forth in numeral 5 of Article 2 of our Constitution, stating that such secrecy and tax secrecy may only be lifted at the request of a judge, the Attorney General or a congressional investigative committee in accordance with the law and provided that they refer to the case under investigation.

On the other hand, we know that the Constitutional Court -in several rulings- has concluded that rights (such as bank secrecy, for example) are not absolute, but relative. Specifying that, in order to determine the level of intensity of an alleged violation of such right or whether such violation is justified or not in constitutional terms, it will be confronted with the Principle of Proportionality.

The Judgment or Principle of Proportionality makes it possible to establish whether the "limiting" measure pursues a constitutional purpose, whether it is suitable with respect to the intended purpose, whether it is necessary because there is no reasonable alternative that is less restrictive of the right invoked and equally effective and, finally, whether the sacrifice demanded on the right claimed is adequate and strictly proportional in relation to the purpose pursued.

For its part, the Constitutional Court, as the highest interpreter of our Constitution, when referring to banking secrecy, has stated that:

"The constitutional protection afforded by banking secrecy seeks to ensure the reserve or confidentiality -both terms used here as synonyms- of a sphere of the private life of individuals or legal persons under private law. Specifically, the necessary confidentiality of the banking operations of any of the subjects described that they may carry out with any entity, public or private, belonging to the banking or financial system.

In this sense, banking secrecy is part of the constitutionally protected content of the right to privacy, and its holder is always the individual or the legal person of private law that carries out such banking or financial operations. To the extent that such banking and financial operations are part of the private life, their knowledge and access can only be lifted at the request of the judge, the Public Prosecutor of the Nation or a Congressional Investigation Commission in accordance with the law and provided that it refers to the case under investigation. Unlike what happens with public information, in which the rule is its publicity and transparency, and the exception is secrecy, in the case of information related to the private life of a person, the rule is always secrecy or confidentiality, while its publicity, subject to an intense control under the test of reasonableness and proportionality, is the exception" [5].

In tax matters, this is not the first time that the constitutionality of a rule related to the "violation" of banking secrecy has been debated. It should be recalled that the Constitutional Court ruled in Case No. 0004-2004-AI/TC regarding the Financial Transaction Tax. In said Decision, it was stated that banking secrecy is a derivation of the right to privacy but allows restrictions or limitations, as long as they are respectful of the Principles of Reasonableness[6] and Proportionality; it also added that the banking right is not part of the essential content of the right to personal privacy.

According to the various pronouncements of our highest interpreter of the Constitution, in order to determine whether Supreme Decree No. 430-2020-EF would have a constitutionally legitimate purpose or whether, on the contrary, it violates the right to banking secrecy, the Principles of Reasonableness and Proportionality would have to be applied.

That is to say, it is necessary to apply a weighting test in order to demonstrate whether the measure implemented by the referred decree is the least restrictive of the universe of measures that could have been adopted; and to ensure that such measure is necessary to achieve the collective good (improve control and inspection actions by SUNAT), or whether, on the contrary, there are other measures equally adequate and lacking in harmful consequences for banking secrecy.

In order to resolve these questions, it is appropriate to mention grounds 41 et seq. of the Judgment issued under Case No. 0004-2004-AI/TC, in which the Constitutional Court stated that:

"...Being the access to information directly related to activities taxed by the FTT, whose time of validity is considerably limited, the restriction of banking secrecy that access to such information implies, is, as an immediate consequence, also temporarily limited, so that the institution is not restricted beyond what is reasonably necessary.

The last paragraph of Article 17 of Law No. 28194 requires financial institutions to also provide information on tax-exempt transactions.

This attribution granted by the challenged norm to the Tax Administration is what motivates the plaintiff to argue that: "(...) the true interest of the State is not to know the tax base of the Tax, but to have access, unduly, to the financial information of the citizens, contrary to the provisions of the Constitution on this matter.

Therefore, for this Court, the last paragraph of Article 17 of Law No. 28194 is incompatible with the principle of reasonableness, since, by granting SUNAT knowledge of operations in the financial system exempted from the FTT, without the intervention of a judicial decision, the Attorney General or a congressional investigative committee, the logical link that sponsored the intervention of the competent tax entity, i.e., the existence of a taxable operation, is broken.

In accordance with the aforementioned grounds, the Constitutional Court is of the idea that there is an enabling assumption to allow SUNAT to access the financial information of taxpayers, this is configured with the existence of a taxable transaction. In addition, the referred tax must have a time limit in the legal system.

From the foregoing, we have that unlike the Financial Transaction Tax, Legislative Decree No. 1434, Supreme Decree No. 430-2020-EF and its Annex do not create and/or apply a tax on passive operations carried out by the clients of the Financial System Companies, but rather they are rules -without any time limit- that enable the simple transfer of information from the financial entities to SUNAT, which violates the fundamental right to banking secrecy.

Likewise, the Constitutional Court indicated in Ground 43 of the aforementioned Ruling that by breaking the relational link between the application of a temporary tax (the FTT) and the transfer of information to SUNAT to which such application gives rise, the last paragraph of Article 17 of Law No. 28194 affects the subprinciple of necessity corresponding to any test of proportionality, since it would imply that the possibility for SUNAT to administer information protected by bank secrecy would be extended indefinitely. In view of this, the Collegiate considered the last paragraph of article 17 of Law No. 28194 unconstitutional, for affecting the Principles of Reasonableness and Proportionality.

In this sense -by all means- and following the reasoning put forward by the Constitutional Court, we conclude that Supreme Decree No. 430-2020-EF violates the fundamental right to banking secrecy, since it empowers SUNAT to be informed of operations that do not imply a relational nexus of "Tax - transfer of sensitive data".

However, the recent regulation of Legislative Decree No. 1434, which resulted in the introduction of Supreme Decree No. 430-2020-EF to our legal system, is due to the fact that Peru recently (December 2020) passed the security and confidentiality examination of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which seeks to ensure that the receipt of our financial information will be safeguarded with first class international standards.

Although the Peruvian commitment to join an international system that has minimum standards -among others- to combat tax evasion and avoidance is applaudable, in no case can it mean that it violates the provisions of our Magna Carta.

On the other hand, there is a fear that this measure may affect the security of taxpayers, either through hackers or SUNAT officials and/or government officials themselves, who could misuse such information.

On the other hand, it could cause people to stop using the financial system, which could lead to an increase in crime and informality.

Leaving aside the constitutional issue, we consider that the legislator should have taken other more suitable measures to combat tax evasion and/or tax avoidance -such as broadening the tax base- since the FTT information is sufficient to administer the taxes collected by SUNAT.

(*) About the author: associate of the tax area of Benites, Vargas y Ugaz Abogados.

Execution time: 0.0004 seconds

Author

Related Entries

Args

post_type
0post
post_statuspublish
posts_per_page2
meta_query
relationAND
0Array ( )
cat
0100
post__not_in
020556
orderby
dateDESC
relevanssitrue

Module Settings

post_type_chooseoff|on|off|off|off|off|off|off|off|off|off
loop_stylecustom_loop_layout
shortcode_name[de_loop_template_shortcode]
loop_templatesdivi-blog
custom_loop_templatenone
loop_layout24694
filter_update_animationload-6
no_posts_layoutnone
no_posts_layout_textSorry, No posts.
is_main_loopon
include_current_termsoff
groupping_post_objectoff
groupping_taxonomynone
show_empty_onloadoff
post_statuspublish
show_current_postoff
posts_number2
post_offset0
post_display_typerelated
saved_typewishlist
acf_linked_acfnone
related_contentcategories
related_acf_fieldnone
related_content_categoriesdefault
is_category_loopoff
disable_sticky_postsoff
specific_post_objectsoff
related_content_tagsdefault
tax_name_relatednone
acf_name_relatednone
custom_tax_choosepost
acf_namenone
include_sticky_postson
include_sticky_posts_onlyoff
onload_tax_choosepost
sort_orderdate
acf_sort_fieldnone
acf_sort_typestring
acf_date_picker_fieldnone
acf_date_picker_methoddefault
acf_date_picker_custom_day30
order_asc_descDESC
sec_acf_sort_fieldnone
sec_acf_sort_typestring
sec_acf_date_picker_fieldnone
sec_order_asc_descASC
enable_loadmoreoff
pagination_positionbottom
scrolltoon
scrollto_fine_tune0px
loadmore_textLoad More
loadmore_text_loadingLoading...
enable_resultcountoff
resultcount_positionright
result_count_single_textShowing the single result
result_count_all_textShowing all %d results
result_count_pagination_textShowing %d-%d of %d results
has_mapoff
map_all_postsoff
map_all_posts_limit-1
map_infoview_layoutnone
map_infoview_layout_ajaxoff
hide_marker_labeloff
map_clusteron
map_center_first_poston
link_whole_girdon
link_whole_gird_externaloff
external_acfnone
content_section_layoutnone
grid_layoutgrid
columns1
columns_tablet1
columns_mobile1
custom_gutter_widthoff
grid_list_defaultlist
grid_list_positionleft
grid_list_cookie_time30
grid_view_icon||divi||400
list_view_icon||fa||900
icon_padding7px|7px|7px|7px
icon_margin0px|10px|0px|0px
enable_overlayon
show_featured_imageon
show_read_moreoff
read_more_textRead More
show_authoron
show_dateon
date_formatF j, Y
show_categorieson
show_contentoff
excerpt_length270
excerpt_more...
show_commentsoff
meta_separator|
content_visibilityhover
image_hover_animationnone
loop_template_content_alignmentcenter_center
loop_template_color_themelight
loop_template_same_heighton
image_min_height150px
image_max_height500px
pagination_item_background#fff
pagination_item_background_active#ebe9eb
_builder_version4.27.0
_module_presetdefault
grouping_tax_title_font_size14px
grouping_tax_title_letter_spacing0px
grouping_tax_title_line_height1em
title_font_size14px
title_letter_spacing0px
title_line_height1em
excerpt_font_size14px
excerpt_letter_spacing0px
excerpt_line_height1em
loop_template_meta_font_size14px
loop_template_meta_letter_spacing0px
loop_template_meta_line_height1em
loop_template_meta_a_font_size14px
loop_template_meta_a_letter_spacing0px
loop_template_meta_a_line_height1em
loop_template_a_font_size14px
loop_template_a_letter_spacing0px
loop_template_a_line_height1em
pagination_font_letter_spacing0px
active_pagination_letter_spacing0px
background_enable_coloron
use_background_color_gradientoff
background_color_gradient_repeatoff
background_color_gradient_typelinear
background_color_gradient_direction180deg
background_color_gradient_direction_radialcenter
background_color_gradient_stops#2b87da 0%|#29c4a9 100%
background_color_gradient_unit%
background_color_gradient_overlays_imageoff
background_color_gradient_start#2b87da
background_color_gradient_start_position0%
background_color_gradient_end#29c4a9
background_color_gradient_end_position100%
background_enable_imageon
parallaxoff
parallax_methodon
background_sizecover
background_image_widthauto
background_image_heightauto
background_positioncenter
background_horizontal_offset0
background_vertical_offset0
background_repeatno-repeat
background_blendnormal
background_enable_video_mp4on
background_enable_video_webmon
allow_player_pauseoff
background_video_pause_outside_viewporton
background_enable_pattern_styleoff
background_pattern_stylepolka-dots
background_pattern_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.2)
background_pattern_sizeinitial
background_pattern_widthauto
background_pattern_heightauto
background_pattern_repeat_origintop_left
background_pattern_horizontal_offset0
background_pattern_vertical_offset0
background_pattern_repeatrepeat
background_pattern_blend_modenormal
background_enable_mask_styleoff
background_mask_stylelayer-blob
background_mask_color#ffffff
background_mask_aspect_ratiolandscape
background_mask_sizestretch
background_mask_widthauto
background_mask_heightauto
background_mask_positioncenter
background_mask_horizontal_offset0
background_mask_vertical_offset0
background_mask_blend_modenormal
custom_buttonoff
button_text_size20
button_bg_use_color_gradientoff
button_bg_color_gradient_repeatoff
button_bg_color_gradient_typelinear
button_bg_color_gradient_direction180deg
button_bg_color_gradient_direction_radialcenter
button_bg_color_gradient_stops#2b87da 0%|#29c4a9 100%
button_bg_color_gradient_unit%
button_bg_color_gradient_overlays_imageoff
button_bg_color_gradient_start#2b87da
button_bg_color_gradient_start_position0%
button_bg_color_gradient_end#29c4a9
button_bg_color_gradient_end_position100%
button_bg_enable_imageon
button_bg_parallaxoff
button_bg_parallax_methodon
button_bg_sizecover
button_bg_image_widthauto
button_bg_image_heightauto
button_bg_positioncenter
button_bg_horizontal_offset0
button_bg_vertical_offset0
button_bg_repeatno-repeat
button_bg_blendnormal
button_bg_enable_video_mp4on
button_bg_enable_video_webmon
button_bg_allow_player_pauseoff
button_bg_video_pause_outside_viewporton
button_use_iconon
button_icon_placementright
button_on_hoveron
custom_loop_template_buttonoff
loop_template_button_text_size20
loop_template_button_bg_use_color_gradientoff
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_repeatoff
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_typelinear
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_direction180deg
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_direction_radialcenter
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_stops#2b87da 0%|#29c4a9 100%
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_unit%
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_overlays_imageoff
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_start#2b87da
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_start_position0%
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_end#29c4a9
loop_template_button_bg_color_gradient_end_position100%
loop_template_button_bg_enable_imageon
loop_template_button_bg_parallaxoff
loop_template_button_bg_parallax_methodon
loop_template_button_bg_sizecover
loop_template_button_bg_image_widthauto
loop_template_button_bg_image_heightauto
loop_template_button_bg_positioncenter
loop_template_button_bg_horizontal_offset0
loop_template_button_bg_vertical_offset0
loop_template_button_bg_repeatno-repeat
loop_template_button_bg_blendnormal
loop_template_button_bg_enable_video_mp4on
loop_template_button_bg_enable_video_webmon
loop_template_button_bg_allow_player_pauseoff
loop_template_button_bg_video_pause_outside_viewporton
loop_template_button_use_iconon
loop_template_button_icon_placementright
loop_template_button_on_hoveron
positioningnone
position_origin_atop_left
position_origin_ftop_left
position_origin_rtop_left
widthauto
max_widthnone
min_heightauto
heightauto
max_heightnone
custom_padding0px|0px|0px|0px|false|false
filter_hue_rotate0deg
filter_saturate100%
filter_brightness100%
filter_contrast100%
filter_invert0%
filter_sepia0%
filter_opacity100%
filter_blur0px
mix_blend_modenormal
animation_stylenone
animation_directioncenter
animation_duration1000ms
animation_delay0ms
animation_intensity_slide50%
animation_intensity_zoom50%
animation_intensity_flip50%
animation_intensity_fold50%
animation_intensity_roll50%
animation_starting_opacity0%
animation_speed_curveease-in-out
animation_repeatonce
hover_transition_duration300ms
hover_transition_delay0ms
hover_transition_speed_curveease
link_option_url_new_windowoff
sticky_positionnone
sticky_offset_top0px
sticky_offset_bottom0px
sticky_limit_topnone
sticky_limit_bottomnone
sticky_offset_surroundingon
sticky_transitionon
motion_trigger_startmiddle
hover_enabled0
custom_css_free_formselector .et_pb_module{margin-bottom:4px!important;}||selector .et_pb_column{padding:0px!important;}||selector .et_pb_with_border{width:100%!important;}||selector h3{font-size:18px!important;}
grouping_tax_title_text_shadow_stylenone
grouping_tax_title_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
grouping_tax_title_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
grouping_tax_title_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
grouping_tax_title_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
title_text_shadow_stylenone
title_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
title_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
title_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
title_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
excerpt_text_shadow_stylenone
excerpt_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
excerpt_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
excerpt_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
excerpt_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
loop_template_meta_text_shadow_stylenone
loop_template_meta_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
loop_template_meta_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
loop_template_meta_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
loop_template_meta_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
loop_template_meta_a_text_shadow_stylenone
loop_template_meta_a_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
loop_template_meta_a_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
loop_template_meta_a_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
loop_template_meta_a_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
loop_template_a_text_shadow_stylenone
loop_template_a_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
loop_template_a_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
loop_template_a_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
loop_template_a_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
pagination_font_text_shadow_stylenone
pagination_font_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
pagination_font_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
pagination_font_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
pagination_font_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
active_pagination_text_shadow_stylenone
active_pagination_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
active_pagination_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
active_pagination_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
active_pagination_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
button_text_shadow_stylenone
button_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
button_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
button_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
button_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
loop_template_button_text_shadow_stylenone
loop_template_button_text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
loop_template_button_text_shadow_vertical_length0em
loop_template_button_text_shadow_blur_strength0em
loop_template_button_text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
box_shadow_stylenone
box_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.3)
box_shadow_positionouter
box_shadow_style_productnone
box_shadow_color_productrgba(0,0,0,0.3)
box_shadow_position_productouter
box_shadow_style_grid_list_view_buttonnone
box_shadow_color_grid_list_view_buttonrgba(0,0,0,0.3)
box_shadow_position_grid_list_view_buttonouter
box_shadow_style_buttonnone
box_shadow_color_buttonrgba(0,0,0,0.3)
box_shadow_position_buttonouter
box_shadow_style_loop_template_buttonnone
box_shadow_color_loop_template_buttonrgba(0,0,0,0.3)
box_shadow_position_loop_template_buttonouter
text_shadow_stylenone
text_shadow_horizontal_length0em
text_shadow_vertical_length0em
text_shadow_blur_strength0em
text_shadow_colorrgba(0,0,0,0.4)
disabledoff
global_colors_info{}
0.091324090957642 seconds